When Great Writers Struggle, and Why That’s Exactly the Point
I just wrapped up Revisionaries: What We Can Learn from the Lost, Unfinished, and Just Plain Bad Work of Great Writers by Kristopher Jansma, and I’ve gotta say, it’s one of those books that gets under your skin in all the right ways. If you’ve ever stared down a blank page wondering if you’re the only one fumbling through the writing process, you’re not. And this book proves it.
It’s 320 pages, broken down into 21 chapters, and each delivers a fascinating deep dive into the messiness behind the masterpieces. We’re talking about Fitzgerald, Harper Lee, Kafka, Jane Austen, Truman Capote, and Octavia Butler, just to name a few. What Jansma does so well is remind us that even the greats stumbled, scrapped drafts, got stuck, rewrote entire books, or failed outright.
Genius Isn’t Magic. It’s Messy.
One of the big ideas Jansma lays out early, and builds on throughout the book, is this: we tend to celebrate literary genius without acknowledging the hard, ugly, behind-the-scenes work. The drafts. The outlines. The charts. The sleepless nights and half-finished pages. We see the polished product, but not the piles of discarded ideas.
Take F. Scott Fitzgerald, for example. The man used word counts, color-coded outlines, character profiles, even a “scavenger file” where he’d toss scraps of ideas to maybe reuse later. That’s not romanticized genius. That’s grit.
Or look at Harper Lee. Her editor didn’t love her first version of To Kill a Mockingbird (Go Set a Watchman) and asked for a complete rewrite. Imagine that. A full rewrite. That moment alone is worth the price of admission.
I Walked Away With a Stack of Note Cards
Seriously, I took somewhere between 30 and 40 note cards while reading. Just idea after idea, technique after technique. Jansma digs into the habits and quirks of writers who refused to give up. Some used dictation. Some wrote with note cards. Some rewrote their books five times by hand (looking at you, David Foster Wallace). Some got blocked and had to write low-stakes stuff to stay in motion. All of it was gold.
And that phrase, “fail like a genius,” really stuck with me. It’s the idea that writing isn’t about perfection. It’s about persistence. It’s about embracing the flaws, the false starts, and the flat-out failures as part of the process.
Writing Tips Wrapped in Storytelling
This isn’t just theory. It’s practical. Jansma offers rewriting strategies (expand your draft, then cut it to a quarter of its size), productivity tricks (schedule your writing, use word goals), and creative hacks (try writing two books at once, one passion project and one obligation, to keep things fun). The idea of play versus work really resonated. Writing should have a spark. A sense of curiosity. A touch of mischief, even.
Final Thoughts
If you’re a writer, you need to read Revisionaries. If you’re a reader curious about how the books you love actually come together, this one’s for you too.
It’s inspiring without being preachy. Encouraging without being fluffy. It reminds us that genius is usually forged through fire and failure. And that maybe, just maybe, our own unfinished drafts aren’t signs of defeat, but signs we’re on the right path.
I loved it, and I’m better for having read it. If you pick it up, I think you will, too.
In the spirit of full disclosure, this is an affiliate link, which means that if you purchase this item through my link, I will earn a commission. You will not pay more when buying a product through my link. I only recommend products & systems that I use and love myself, so I know you’ll be in good hands.
Plus, ordering through my link helps me continue offering you lots of free stuff. 🙂 Thank you in advance for your support!
